PEER REVIEW PROCESS
Every article submitted to JPSTM (Journal of Social and Community Technology Empowerment Service) undergoes a rigorous and independent peer review process to ensure scientific quality, novelty, and the relevance of the manuscript's content to the focus and scope of the journal.
JPSTM utilizes a Double-Blind Peer Review system (where both the authors' and reviewers' identities are kept confidential from each other) to guarantee the objectivity and integrity of the evaluation process.
Review Stages
The article review process from initial submission to the final decision goes through the following stages:
1. Initial Editorial Screening
- Duration: ± 3–7 working days from manuscript receipt.
- Process: The Managing Editor and the Editorial Board check the administrative completeness of the manuscript, format compliance with the Author Guidelines and journal template, alignment with the community service focus and scope (Focus and Scope), and the similarity level of the manuscript using plagiarism detection software (Plagiarism Checker).
- Decision: Manuscripts that do not meet the minimum criteria will be directly rejected (Desk Reject) or returned to the authors for revision before proceeding to the substantive review stage.
2. Reviewer Assignment
- Process: Manuscripts that pass the initial screening stage will be sent to at least 2 (two) Reviewers who possess expertise or fields relevant to the manuscript's topic. Reviewers are selected independently and must not originate from the same institution as the authors to avoid conflicts of interest.
3. Substantive Peer Review
- Duration: ± 2–4 weeks.
- Evaluation Criteria: Reviewers evaluate the manuscript based on several key aspects:
- Community Service Substance: Depth of target partner problem analysis, appropriateness of the empowerment approach methodology, and active community involvement.
- Novelty and Contribution: Significance of the activity outcomes toward the application of Science and Technology (IPTEK) for the community.
- Methodology and Evaluation: Clarity of activity implementation stages, success indicators, and program evaluation.
- Writing Quality: Writing structure, language clarity, completeness of tables/figures, and up-to-date references (citations).
4. Editorial Decision
Based on the reviews and recommendations from the Reviewers, the Editorial Board will make one of the following decisions:
- Accepted: The manuscript is approved for publication without revisions or requiring only minor grammar enhancements.
- Revisions Required (Minor/Major Revision): Authors are given the opportunity to revise the manuscript according to the reviewer's notes and recommendations within a specified timeframe.
- Resubmit for Review: The manuscript requires substantial restructuring and must go through a re-review process from the beginning.
- Rejected: The manuscript is rejected due to failure to meet journal quality standards, low novelty, or fatal methodological flaws.
5. Revision & Publication
- Authors whose manuscripts require revision must re-upload the revised manuscript along with a written response to the reviewer's notes (response to reviewer).
- Once the manuscript is declared Accepted, it will enter the layout editing, copyediting, and online publication stages within the regular JPSTM publication issue.









